Quick answer
My Paycheck Calculator is our pick for best overall. Of the six, it covers the most tax situations: city and county income taxes in 14 states, RSUs and stock options, investment and self-employment income, a refund or amount-owed estimate, and tax years 2021 through 2027, with no ads and no account. Pay44 has the most App Store ratings and has been on the App Store since 2019, four years longer than My Paycheck Calculator, and it is a good choice if you also want a budget planner. For gross-up, bonus, or W-4 questions in a browser, use PaycheckCity.
Top picks by need
- Best overall: My Paycheck Calculator. It covers the most tax situations of the six: local taxes in 14 states, stock compensation, investment income, refunds, and tax years 2021 through 2027.
- Most App Store ratings: Pay44. A 4.9 average from about 13,000 ratings since its release in 2019, with a budget planner.
- Most specialized calculators: PaycheckCity. Gross-up, bonus tax, and Form W-4 tools on the web.
- Quickest browser estimate: SmartAsset. One page, nothing to install.
- Best if your employer uses ADP: ADP Mobile Solutions. Your real pay statements instead of estimates.
- Best one-time purchase: Payroll Guru. $4.99 once, no subscription.
Side-by-side comparison
| Tool | Platforms | App Store rating (US) | Price | Ads | States | Local taxes | Tax years | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| My Paycheck Calculator | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android, web | 4.7 (245) | Free + Pro | None | 50 + D.C. | Yes, 14 states | 2021–2027 | Best overall |
| Pay44 | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android | 4.9 (about 13,000) | Free + Pro | None | 50 + D.C. + Puerto Rico | No | 2026 | Budgeting |
| PaycheckCity | Web | No app | Free | Own payroll product | 50 + D.C. + 5 territories | Yes | By check date | Gross-up, bonus, and W-4 |
| SmartAsset | Web | No app | No charge listed | Yes | 50 + D.C. | Yes | Not listed | Quick browser estimate |
| ADP | Web, plus the ADP Mobile Solutions payroll app | No calculator app | No charge listed | ADP payroll services | 50 | Not listed | Current rates | Employees of ADP clients |
| Payroll Guru | iPhone, iPad, Android | 3.3 (40) | $4.99 one-time | None listed; ads in Paycheck Lite | 50 + D.C. | Not listed | Current year | Paying once |
Ratings are US App Store averages with the number of ratings in parentheses, as of November 15, 2026. "Not listed" means we did not find it on the product's public pages. It is not a claim that the product cannot do it.
The six calculators
My Paycheck Calculator · Best overall
Our app. It estimates take-home pay for the whole tax year instead of a single check, so wages, bonuses, equity, and investment income are taxed together, and it shows whether you are on track for a refund or a balance due.
Key features:
- Federal, state, and local income tax for all 50 states and D.C., with city and county taxes in 14 states
- Tax years 2021 through 2027
- Salary, hourly, overtime, bonuses, commissions, tips, ISOs, NSOs, RSUs, dividends, interest, capital gains, self-employment, rental income, and Social Security benefits
- Refund or amount-owed estimate, side-by-side comparison, tax bracket charts, and retirement projections
- Export to PDF, Excel, CSV, and image
Pros:
- Covers local taxes, equity, and investment income in one estimate
- No ads and no account
- Runs on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, and Android, with a free web calculator
Cons:
- Newer than Pay44, with fewer ratings: 245 on the US App Store since its 2023 release
- Most features beyond a 2026 paycheck estimate need the Pro subscription
- No budget planner, gross-up calculator, or Form W-4 wizard
- English only, and no Puerto Rico or other territories
Best for: People with a city or county income tax, RSUs or stock options, investment or self-employment income, or a job offer to compare.
Download · Free web calculator
Pay44 (Paycheck Calculator US) · Most App Store ratings
The dedicated paycheck calculator with the most ratings on the US App Store, where it has been available since October 2019. It has a budget planner built in.
Key features:
- Federal and state income tax for all 50 states, D.C., and Puerto Rico
- Budget planner that combines paychecks with income and expenses
- Paycheck comparison and what-if scenarios
- Export to PDF, image, CSV, and text
- 10 languages
Pros:
- 4.9 average from about 13,000 App Store ratings
- No ads and no account
- Budgeting and payday reminders
Cons:
- Its own comparison pages say the app does not calculate local or city taxes
- Stock compensation, investment income, and refund estimates are not listed in its App Store description
- 2026 tax brackets only
Best for: A quick paycheck estimate on your phone, with budgeting.
My Paycheck Calculator vs Pay44 · App Store
PaycheckCity · Most specialized calculators
A long-running set of free web calculators from Symmetry Software, online since 1999.
Key features:
- Salary, hourly, bonus (two methods), gross-up, tip, 401(k), and dual scenario calculators
- Step-by-step Form W-4 with download and print
- All 50 states, D.C., and five US territories, with local taxes
Pros:
- Free
- Gross-up and bonus calculations that most apps skip
- Covers US territories
Cons:
- No mobile app
- Works one paycheck at a time; stock compensation, investment income, and refund estimates are not listed
- No tax year picker: rates follow the check date
Best for: Gross-up, bonus tax, and W-4 questions in a browser.
My Paycheck Calculator vs PaycheckCity · Website
SmartAsset paycheck calculator · Quick browser estimate
A single web page that returns a paycheck breakdown, surrounded by a guide to how paychecks are taxed.
Key features:
- Salary or hourly pay with overtime
- Federal, state, and local income tax lines, plus state insurance taxes
- Nine named pre-tax deductions, including 401(k), HSA, and FSA
- State-by-state guides
Pros:
- Nothing to install
- Clear written explanations
- Related tax calculators on the same site
Cons:
- No app
- Shows savings-rate offers and financial advisor matching
- Bonuses, stock compensation, and investment income are not listed in the paycheck calculator
- The page does not say which tax year it uses
Best for: A fast estimate without downloading anything.
My Paycheck Calculator vs SmartAsset · Website
ADP calculators and ADP Mobile Solutions · Best if your employer uses ADP
Two separate products. ADP's web calculators give employers a gross-to-net estimate. The ADP Mobile Solutions app shows real pay statements, and only to employees of companies that use ADP.
Key features:
- Salary, hourly (up to six rates), and gross pay calculators for all 50 states
- ADP Mobile Solutions: pay statements, W-2s, and time tracking
Pros:
- Actual pay data if your employer uses ADP
- Gross Pay Calculator works back from the net pay you want
- About 4.5 million App Store ratings for ADP Mobile Solutions
Cons:
- The app is not a calculator and is unavailable unless your employer uses ADP
- Calculator pages are written for employers
- A local tax input, stock compensation, and refund estimates are not listed
Best for: Employees of ADP clients who want real pay statements, and employers who want a quick figure.
My Paycheck Calculator vs ADP · Website
Payroll Guru · One-time purchase
A paycheck calculator app sold for $4.99 with no subscription, listed as Payrollguru on the App Store. Paycheck Lite is its free, ad-supported version.
Key features:
- Federal and state withholding, Social Security, Medicare, state unemployment, and state disability insurance
- Salary and hourly pay with overtime and double time
- Up to 8 pre-tax or post-tax deductions and unlimited profiles
- Email paycheck details
Pros:
- Pay once
- Updated for 2026
- Free version available
Cons:
- Low ratings: 3.3 from 40 for the paid app and 2.5 from 162 for Paycheck Lite
- City and county taxes are not listed
- Stock compensation, investment income, and refund estimates are not listed
Best for: A basic federal and state calculation without a subscription.
My Paycheck Calculator vs Payroll Guru · App Store
How we compared
- Coverage. States, city and county taxes, and tax years.
- Income types. Whether the tool handles pay beyond a salary: overtime, bonuses, equity, investments, and self-employment.
- Planning. Refund estimates, comparisons, and projections.
- Platform. App, web, or both.
- Cost. Price, subscriptions, and ads.
- What we did not do. We did not test the other products against pay stubs. Everything about them comes from their own public descriptions, linked under Sources.
FAQ
Which paycheck calculator is best?
My Paycheck Calculator is our pick for best overall, and it is our app. It covers the most tax situations of the six: city and county taxes in 14 states, stock compensation, investment income, refunds, and tax years 2021 through 2027. Pay44 has the most App Store ratings, has been on the App Store since 2019, and includes a budget planner. PaycheckCity has the most specialized web calculators, SmartAsset is a quick browser estimate, ADP Mobile Solutions shows real pay statements if your employer uses ADP, and Payroll Guru is a one-time purchase.
Which paycheck calculators have an app?
My Paycheck Calculator, Pay44, and Payroll Guru are apps for iPhone and Android. PaycheckCity and SmartAsset are web only as of November 15, 2026. ADP's calculators are web pages, and its ADP Mobile Solutions app is a payroll portal for employees of companies that use ADP.
Which paycheck calculators include city and county taxes?
My Paycheck Calculator includes city and county income taxes in 14 states. PaycheckCity and SmartAsset include local taxes in their web calculators. Pay44's own comparison pages say its app does not calculate local or city taxes, and Payroll Guru's App Store listing does not list them.
Which paycheck calculator handles RSUs and stock options?
Of the six, My Paycheck Calculator is the only one where we found stock compensation listed as of November 15, 2026. It supports ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs.
Are paycheck calculators accurate?
They are estimates. A calculator applies the published federal, state, and local tax rules to the numbers you enter. Your actual paycheck can differ because of your W-4 elections, benefit deductions, how your employer's payroll system handles bonuses, and mid-year changes.
Are these calculators free?
PaycheckCity's calculators are free, and SmartAsset's and ADP's list no charge. My Paycheck Calculator and Pay44 are free to download with optional Pro subscriptions. Payroll Guru is a one-time $4.99 purchase with a free, ad-supported version called Paycheck Lite.
Individual comparisons
- My Paycheck Calculator vs Pay44
- My Paycheck Calculator vs PaycheckCity
- My Paycheck Calculator vs SmartAsset
- My Paycheck Calculator vs ADP
- My Paycheck Calculator vs Payroll Guru
Sources
- My Paycheck Calculator on the App Store
- Paycheck Calculator US - Pay44 on the App Store
- Pay44 comparison pages
- PaycheckCity calculators
- PaycheckCity: Our Story
- SmartAsset paycheck calculator
- ADP payroll calculators
- ADP Mobile Solutions on the App Store
- Payrollguru on the App Store
- Paycheck Lite : Mobile Payroll on the App Store