The short version
- Choose Pay44 if you want a quick paycheck estimate with a built-in budget planner, you live in Puerto Rico, or you want the app in a language other than English.
- Choose My Paycheck Calculator if you pay a city or county income tax, have RSUs or stock options, have investment, rental, or self-employment income, earned income in more than one state, or want to know whether you will get a refund or owe.
Feature comparison
| Feature | My Paycheck Calculator | Pay44 |
|---|---|---|
| App Store rating (US) | 4.7 from 245 ratings | 4.9 from about 13,000 ratings |
| Platforms | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android, web | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android, web |
| Price | Free, optional Pro subscription | Free, optional Pro subscription |
| Ads | None | None |
| Account required | No | No |
| Federal and state income tax | All 50 states and D.C. | All 50 states, D.C., and Puerto Rico |
| City and county income taxes | Yes, in 14 states | No, per Pay44's own comparison pages |
| Tax years | 2021 through 2027 | 2026 |
| Salary, hourly, overtime, bonus, commission, tips | Yes | Yes |
| Stock compensation (ISOs, NSOs, RSUs) | Yes | Not listed |
| Investment income and capital gains | Yes | Not listed |
| Self-employment and rental income | Yes | Not listed |
| Income in more than one state | Yes | Not listed |
| Multiple employers | Yes | Multiple saved paychecks |
| Refund or amount-owed estimate | Yes: federal, state, and local | Not listed |
| Tax credits (Child Tax Credit, EITC) | Yes | W-4 dependents input |
| Itemized deductions | Yes | Not listed |
| 401(k), HSA, FSA, health insurance | Yes, plus IRAs and employer match | Yes |
| Retirement projections | Yes | Not listed |
| Side-by-side comparison | Yes | Yes |
| Tax bracket charts | Yes | Effective rate and tax split |
| Budget planner | No | Yes |
| Export | PDF, Excel, CSV, image | PDF, image, CSV, text |
| Reminders | Tax deadlines | Paydays |
| Languages | English | 10 languages |
"Not listed" means the feature does not appear in Pay44's App Store description as of November 14, 2026. It is not a claim that the app cannot do it.
Where Pay44 is stronger
- Ratings. Pay44 has about 13,000 App Store ratings with a 4.9 average. My Paycheck Calculator has 245 with a 4.7 average. Pay44 was released in 2019 and My Paycheck Calculator in 2023.
- Budgeting. Pay44 combines paychecks with income and expense items in a budget planner. My Paycheck Calculator has no budget planner.
- Languages and territories. Pay44 is available in 10 languages and supports Puerto Rico. My Paycheck Calculator is in English and covers the 50 states and D.C.
- Payday reminders. Pay44 can remind you of paydays. My Paycheck Calculator's reminders are for tax deadlines.
Where My Paycheck Calculator is stronger
- Local taxes. City and county income taxes are included for 14 states: Alabama, Colorado, Delaware, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Oregon, and Pennsylvania. That matters if you live or work somewhere like New York City, Philadelphia, Columbus, Detroit, or a Maryland or Indiana county.
- Tax years. Seven tax years, 2021 through 2027, so you can check a past year or plan next year's take-home pay. The 2026 year is free.
- Equity compensation. ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs, with net-share estimates for vesting and exercise.
- Income beyond a paycheck. Dividends, interest, capital gains and losses, rental income, self-employment income, and Social Security benefits are all taxed together with your wages.
- Your year-end position. Enter what you have had withheld or paid in estimates and see a refund or balance due for federal, state, and local.
- Moves and multiple jobs. Income in more than one state in a year, and multiple employers with separate 401(k) contributions.
- Planning. Retirement projections, tax bracket charts, and suggestions such as unused 401(k) room.
Price
Both apps are free to download, show no ads, and offer an optional Pro subscription with weekly, monthly, and annual plans. In My Paycheck Calculator, a paycheck estimate for the 2026 tax year is free. MyPay Pro adds the other tax years, stock compensation, long-term capital gains, multiple states and employers, refund estimates, comparisons, tax bracket charts, projections, iCloud sync, and exports. Current prices for both apps are shown on their App Store pages.
FAQ
Which is better, My Paycheck Calculator or Pay44?
It depends on what you need. Pay44 has far more App Store ratings, a budget planner, Puerto Rico support, and 10 languages. My Paycheck Calculator covers more of the tax picture: city and county taxes in 14 states, tax years 2021 through 2027, stock compensation, investment and self-employment income, multi-state income, and a refund or amount-owed estimate.
Does Pay44 calculate local city and county taxes?
Not in the app. Pay44's own comparison pages, as of November 15, 2026, list local and city taxes as "No" for Pay44, and its website has a separate local income tax calculator. My Paycheck Calculator includes city and county income taxes in 14 states as part of the estimate.
Are both apps free?
Both are free to download with no ads, and both offer an optional Pro subscription. In My Paycheck Calculator, the 2026 tax year is free and MyPay Pro adds the other tax years, stock compensation, comparisons, refund estimates, and exports.
Which app handles RSUs and stock options?
My Paycheck Calculator supports ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs, including net-share estimates. Pay44's App Store description, as of November 14, 2026, does not list stock compensation.