My Paycheck Calculator vs Pay44

Both apps estimate US take-home pay and both are free to download. Pay44 has been on the App Store since 2019, has more ratings, and includes a budget planner. My Paycheck Calculator covers more of the tax picture, including local taxes, equity, investment income, and past and future tax years.

Disclosure: My Paycheck Calculator is our app. Pay44 details come from its public App Store listing as of November 14, 2026, and its website as of November 15, 2026. If something here is out of date, email trip@mypayapp.io and we will correct it.

The short version

Feature comparison

FeatureMy Paycheck CalculatorPay44
App Store rating (US)4.7 from 245 ratings4.9 from about 13,000 ratings
PlatformsiPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android, webiPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android, web
PriceFree, optional Pro subscriptionFree, optional Pro subscription
AdsNoneNone
Account requiredNoNo
Federal and state income taxAll 50 states and D.C.All 50 states, D.C., and Puerto Rico
City and county income taxesYes, in 14 statesNo, per Pay44's own comparison pages
Tax years2021 through 20272026
Salary, hourly, overtime, bonus, commission, tipsYesYes
Stock compensation (ISOs, NSOs, RSUs)YesNot listed
Investment income and capital gainsYesNot listed
Self-employment and rental incomeYesNot listed
Income in more than one stateYesNot listed
Multiple employersYesMultiple saved paychecks
Refund or amount-owed estimateYes: federal, state, and localNot listed
Tax credits (Child Tax Credit, EITC)YesW-4 dependents input
Itemized deductionsYesNot listed
401(k), HSA, FSA, health insuranceYes, plus IRAs and employer matchYes
Retirement projectionsYesNot listed
Side-by-side comparisonYesYes
Tax bracket chartsYesEffective rate and tax split
Budget plannerNoYes
ExportPDF, Excel, CSV, imagePDF, image, CSV, text
RemindersTax deadlinesPaydays
LanguagesEnglish10 languages

"Not listed" means the feature does not appear in Pay44's App Store description as of November 14, 2026. It is not a claim that the app cannot do it.

Where Pay44 is stronger

Where My Paycheck Calculator is stronger

Price

Both apps are free to download, show no ads, and offer an optional Pro subscription with weekly, monthly, and annual plans. In My Paycheck Calculator, a paycheck estimate for the 2026 tax year is free. MyPay Pro adds the other tax years, stock compensation, long-term capital gains, multiple states and employers, refund estimates, comparisons, tax bracket charts, projections, iCloud sync, and exports. Current prices for both apps are shown on their App Store pages.

FAQ

Which is better, My Paycheck Calculator or Pay44?

It depends on what you need. Pay44 has far more App Store ratings, a budget planner, Puerto Rico support, and 10 languages. My Paycheck Calculator covers more of the tax picture: city and county taxes in 14 states, tax years 2021 through 2027, stock compensation, investment and self-employment income, multi-state income, and a refund or amount-owed estimate.

Does Pay44 calculate local city and county taxes?

Not in the app. Pay44's own comparison pages, as of November 15, 2026, list local and city taxes as "No" for Pay44, and its website has a separate local income tax calculator. My Paycheck Calculator includes city and county income taxes in 14 states as part of the estimate.

Are both apps free?

Both are free to download with no ads, and both offer an optional Pro subscription. In My Paycheck Calculator, the 2026 tax year is free and MyPay Pro adds the other tax years, stock compensation, comparisons, refund estimates, and exports.

Which app handles RSUs and stock options?

My Paycheck Calculator supports ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs, including net-share estimates. Pay44's App Store description, as of November 14, 2026, does not list stock compensation.

Try My Paycheck Calculator

Free to download. No account and no ads.

Get the App