My Paycheck Calculator vs PaycheckCity

PaycheckCity is a set of free web calculators from Symmetry Software, including bonus, gross-up, and Form W-4 tools that My Paycheck Calculator does not have. My Paycheck Calculator is an app for iPhone, iPad, Mac, and Android that covers the whole tax year: equity, investment income, refunds, and seven tax years.

Disclosure: My Paycheck Calculator is our app. PaycheckCity details come from paycheckcity.com as of November 15, 2026. We did not run test calculations in the other products. If something here is out of date, email trip@mypayapp.io and we will correct it.

The short version

Feature comparison

FeatureMy Paycheck CalculatorPaycheckCity
TypeMobile and desktop app, plus a free web calculatorWeb calculators
PlatformsiPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android, webWeb. No mobile app: PaycheckCity says it retired its app in 2014
App Store rating (US)4.7 from 245 ratingsNo app
PriceFree; optional Pro subscriptionCalculators are free. A separate small-business payroll product costs $228 a year
AdsNonePromotes its own payroll product
Account requiredNoNot listed
Federal and state income taxAll 50 states and D.C.All 50 states, D.C., and five US territories
City and county income taxesYes, in 14 statesYes
Tax years2021 through 2027Uses current tax tables for the check date you enter
Salary and hourly payYesYes, as separate calculators
Overtime, bonus, commission, tipsYesUp to six hourly rates, an additional-income field for tips or commissions, and two bonus calculators
Stock compensation (ISOs, NSOs, RSUs)YesNot listed
Investment income and capital gainsYesNot listed
Self-employment and rental incomeYesNot listed
Refund or amount-owed estimateYes: federal, state, and localNot listed
Itemized deductions and tax creditsYesChild Tax Credit calculator and W-4 dependents; itemized deductions not listed
401(k), IRA, HSA, FSAYes, with employer match and contribution limits401(k) calculator, plus benefits and deductions you mark as pre-tax or post-tax
Side-by-side comparisonYesYes: dual scenario salary and hourly calculators
Retirement projectionsYesProjected annual 401(k) savings
Gross-up (net pay to gross pay)NoYes
Form W-4 wizardNoYes, with download and print
ExportPDF, Excel, CSV, imagePrint

"Not listed" means we did not find the feature on the paycheckcity.com pages we read as of November 15, 2026. It is not a claim that the product cannot do it.

Where PaycheckCity is stronger

Where My Paycheck Calculator is stronger

Price

PaycheckCity's calculators are free. Its paid product, PaycheckCity Payroll, is aimed at small businesses and costs $228 a year. My Paycheck Calculator is free to download with no ads. A paycheck estimate for the 2026 tax year is free, and so is the web calculator on this site. MyPay Pro is an optional subscription that adds the other tax years, stock compensation, long-term capital gains, multiple states and employers, refund estimates, comparisons, tax bracket charts, projections, iCloud sync, and exports. Current prices are shown in the app.

FAQ

Does PaycheckCity have a mobile app?

No. PaycheckCity's company timeline says it built a mobile app in 2012 and retired it in 2014, and we found no PaycheckCity app on the US App Store or Google Play as of November 15, 2026. My Paycheck Calculator is available for iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, and Android.

Is PaycheckCity free?

The PaycheckCity paycheck calculators are free. PaycheckCity Payroll, a separate product for small businesses, costs $228 a year.

Which one calculates local taxes?

Both. PaycheckCity includes local taxes in its results where they apply. My Paycheck Calculator includes city and county income taxes in 14 states.

Which should I use for a gross-up or bonus calculation?

PaycheckCity. It has a gross-up calculator and two bonus tax calculators. My Paycheck Calculator includes bonuses as income in your annual estimate but has no gross-up calculator.

Which handles RSUs and stock options?

My Paycheck Calculator supports ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs. We did not find stock compensation on the PaycheckCity pages we read as of November 15, 2026.

Try My Paycheck Calculator

Free to download. No account and no ads.

Get the App