The short version
- Choose PaycheckCity if you want a single paycheck worked out in a browser, need a gross-up or bonus-tax calculation, want help filling out Form W-4, or live in a US territory.
- Choose My Paycheck Calculator if you want an app on your phone or Mac, have RSUs or stock options, have investment, rental, or self-employment income, want a refund or amount-owed estimate, or want to look at a past or future tax year.
Feature comparison
| Feature | My Paycheck Calculator | PaycheckCity |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Mobile and desktop app, plus a free web calculator | Web calculators |
| Platforms | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android, web | Web. No mobile app: PaycheckCity says it retired its app in 2014 |
| App Store rating (US) | 4.7 from 245 ratings | No app |
| Price | Free; optional Pro subscription | Calculators are free. A separate small-business payroll product costs $228 a year |
| Ads | None | Promotes its own payroll product |
| Account required | No | Not listed |
| Federal and state income tax | All 50 states and D.C. | All 50 states, D.C., and five US territories |
| City and county income taxes | Yes, in 14 states | Yes |
| Tax years | 2021 through 2027 | Uses current tax tables for the check date you enter |
| Salary and hourly pay | Yes | Yes, as separate calculators |
| Overtime, bonus, commission, tips | Yes | Up to six hourly rates, an additional-income field for tips or commissions, and two bonus calculators |
| Stock compensation (ISOs, NSOs, RSUs) | Yes | Not listed |
| Investment income and capital gains | Yes | Not listed |
| Self-employment and rental income | Yes | Not listed |
| Refund or amount-owed estimate | Yes: federal, state, and local | Not listed |
| Itemized deductions and tax credits | Yes | Child Tax Credit calculator and W-4 dependents; itemized deductions not listed |
| 401(k), IRA, HSA, FSA | Yes, with employer match and contribution limits | 401(k) calculator, plus benefits and deductions you mark as pre-tax or post-tax |
| Side-by-side comparison | Yes | Yes: dual scenario salary and hourly calculators |
| Retirement projections | Yes | Projected annual 401(k) savings |
| Gross-up (net pay to gross pay) | No | Yes |
| Form W-4 wizard | No | Yes, with download and print |
| Export | PDF, Excel, CSV, image |
"Not listed" means we did not find the feature on the paycheckcity.com pages we read as of November 15, 2026. It is not a claim that the product cannot do it.
Where PaycheckCity is stronger
- Specialized paycheck calculators. PaycheckCity has separate tools for gross-up (start from the net pay you want), bonus tax by the flat-percentage and aggregate methods, tips, 401(k) changes, marriage, and divorce.
- Form W-4. A step-by-step electronic W-4 that you can download and print, plus state withholding forms.
- Territories. Calculator pages for Puerto Rico, Guam, American Samoa, the Northern Mariana Islands, and the US Virgin Islands. My Paycheck Calculator covers the 50 states and D.C.
- Nothing to install. Everything runs in a browser. My Paycheck Calculator's web calculator is simpler than its app.
- Track record. PaycheckCity has been online since 1999 and runs on the Symmetry Tax Engine used by payroll providers.
Where My Paycheck Calculator is stronger
- An app. My Paycheck Calculator runs on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, and Android, saves your inputs, and syncs with iCloud if you want it to. PaycheckCity is web only.
- The whole tax year, not one check. Wages are taxed together with dividends, interest, capital gains and losses, rental income, self-employment income, and Social Security benefits.
- Equity compensation. ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs, with net-share estimates.
- Refund or amount owed. Enter what you have had withheld or paid in estimates and see your position for federal, state, and local.
- Tax years. Seven selectable tax years, 2021 through 2027.
- Planning. Itemized deductions, tax bracket charts, retirement projections, and multi-year history.
Price
PaycheckCity's calculators are free. Its paid product, PaycheckCity Payroll, is aimed at small businesses and costs $228 a year. My Paycheck Calculator is free to download with no ads. A paycheck estimate for the 2026 tax year is free, and so is the web calculator on this site. MyPay Pro is an optional subscription that adds the other tax years, stock compensation, long-term capital gains, multiple states and employers, refund estimates, comparisons, tax bracket charts, projections, iCloud sync, and exports. Current prices are shown in the app.
FAQ
Does PaycheckCity have a mobile app?
No. PaycheckCity's company timeline says it built a mobile app in 2012 and retired it in 2014, and we found no PaycheckCity app on the US App Store or Google Play as of November 15, 2026. My Paycheck Calculator is available for iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, and Android.
Is PaycheckCity free?
The PaycheckCity paycheck calculators are free. PaycheckCity Payroll, a separate product for small businesses, costs $228 a year.
Which one calculates local taxes?
Both. PaycheckCity includes local taxes in its results where they apply. My Paycheck Calculator includes city and county income taxes in 14 states.
Which should I use for a gross-up or bonus calculation?
PaycheckCity. It has a gross-up calculator and two bonus tax calculators. My Paycheck Calculator includes bonuses as income in your annual estimate but has no gross-up calculator.
Which handles RSUs and stock options?
My Paycheck Calculator supports ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs. We did not find stock compensation on the PaycheckCity pages we read as of November 15, 2026.