The short version
- Choose SmartAsset if you want a quick estimate in a browser with nothing to install, along with written guides to each state's taxes.
- Choose My Paycheck Calculator if you want an app with no ads, have RSUs or stock options, want wages, investments, and self-employment income in one estimate, or want to compare scenarios and export the result.
Feature comparison
| Feature | My Paycheck Calculator | SmartAsset paycheck calculator |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Mobile and desktop app, plus a free web calculator | Web calculator |
| Platforms | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, Android, web | Web. We found no SmartAsset app on the US App Store or Google Play |
| App Store rating (US) | 4.7 from 245 ratings | No app |
| Price | Free; optional Pro subscription | No charge listed |
| Ads | None | Yes: savings-rate offers and financial advisor matching |
| Account required | No | No sign-in requirement listed |
| Federal and state income tax | All 50 states and D.C. | All 50 states and D.C. |
| City and county income taxes | Yes, in 14 states | Yes: results include a local income tax line |
| Tax years | 2021 through 2027 | Not listed |
| Salary and hourly pay | Yes | Yes |
| Overtime, bonus, commission, tips | Yes | Overtime; bonus, commission, and tips not listed |
| Stock compensation (ISOs, NSOs, RSUs) | Yes | Not listed |
| Investment income and capital gains | Yes | In a separate tax return calculator |
| Self-employment and rental income | Yes | Not listed |
| Refund or amount-owed estimate | Yes: federal, state, and local | In a separate tax return calculator |
| Itemized deductions and tax credits | Yes | In a separate income tax calculator |
| 401(k), IRA, HSA, FSA | Yes, with employer match and contribution limits | 401(k), HSA, and FSA; IRA in a separate calculator |
| Side-by-side comparison | Yes | Not listed |
| Retirement projections | Yes | Not listed |
| Gross-up (net pay to gross pay) | No | Not listed |
| Form W-4 wizard | No | No wizard; allowances and additional withholding inputs |
| Export | PDF, Excel, CSV, image | Not listed |
"Not listed" means we did not find the feature on the smartasset.com paycheck calculator pages we read as of November 15, 2026. It is not a claim that the product cannot do it.
Where SmartAsset is stronger
- Nothing to install. One web page, with results on the same screen.
- Explanations. The calculator sits inside a long guide to how paychecks are taxed, and each state has its own page.
- Payroll line items. Results list state disability, unemployment, family leave, and workers' compensation insurance taxes separately, and you can mark yourself exempt from individual taxes.
- Related calculators. SmartAsset also has income tax, tax return, capital gains, property tax, and retirement tax calculators, each on its own page.
Where My Paycheck Calculator is stronger
- No ads. SmartAsset's page carries savings-rate offers and financial advisor matching, and SmartAsset is paid by advisers. My Paycheck Calculator shows no ads.
- One estimate instead of several calculators. Wages, bonuses, equity, dividends, interest, capital gains, rental income, and self-employment income are taxed together, with a refund or amount owed at the end.
- Equity compensation. ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs, with net-share estimates.
- Tax years. Seven selectable tax years, 2021 through 2027. SmartAsset's paycheck calculator page does not say which tax year it uses.
- Comparison and export. Compare two scenarios side by side and export to PDF, Excel, CSV, or an image.
- An app that keeps your numbers. Saved inputs, multiple employers, income in more than one state, and optional iCloud sync.
Price
SmartAsset's paycheck calculator lists no charge. SmartAsset earns money from financial advisor matching and savings-rate offers shown on the page. My Paycheck Calculator is free to download with no ads. A paycheck estimate for the 2026 tax year is free, and so is the web calculator on this site. MyPay Pro is an optional subscription that adds the other tax years, stock compensation, long-term capital gains, multiple states and employers, refund estimates, comparisons, tax bracket charts, projections, iCloud sync, and exports. Current prices are shown in the app.
FAQ
Does SmartAsset have a paycheck calculator app?
We found no SmartAsset app on the US App Store or Google Play as of November 15, 2026. Its paycheck calculator is a web page. My Paycheck Calculator is available for iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision, and Android.
Does the SmartAsset paycheck calculator show ads?
Yes. The page includes savings-rate offers and financial advisor matching, and SmartAsset discloses that it receives compensation from advisers. My Paycheck Calculator shows no ads.
Which one calculates local taxes?
Both. SmartAsset's results include a local income tax line. My Paycheck Calculator includes city and county income taxes in 14 states.
Which handles RSUs and stock options?
My Paycheck Calculator supports ISOs, NSOs, and RSUs. We did not find stock compensation on the SmartAsset paycheck calculator pages we read as of November 15, 2026.